When AI shows up without an invite

Imagine you’re hosting a dinner party. You’ve set the table, prepped the menu and invited the people you really want to get to know – and then someone unexpected shows up. That’s hiring right now. Interviewing was already a heavy lift, and now AI is showing up uninvited, nudging both candidates and employers to rethink their approaches. Applicants arrive more “prepared,” “polished” and often more scripted, while teams automate steps just to stay above water. No surprise the room feels different: more than half of U.S. job seekers (54%) told Greenhouse they’ve already had an AI-led interview.

CNN’s recent article lays out the tension. When AI helps candidates apply everywhere at once or smooth out their answers, application volume spikes and the signals recruiters once relied on to identify strong fits become harder to read. Candidates see it as them adapting to the market, which results in employers countering with more automation. This results in the “doom loop” Daniel Chait warns about where no one feels truly seen or supported.

So what now? Let’s not kick our AI guest out – let’s take back control of the party and remember what we’re here to do. Structured interviews, shared scorecards and intentional questions cut through superficial shine and surface the qualities that matter most: judgment, experience and adaptability. AI may influence how candidates arrive, but human-led rigor ensures the right people stay.

The Recruiter’s Desk: Interview tips for making the right hire

Welcome back to the Recruiter’s Desk, where we spotlight what hiring teams are seeing on the ground and share practical guidance from talent leaders. The view from the chair right now? AI is quietly slipping into interviews – new Greenhouse data shows that 35% of recruiters say they’ve observed candidates using it in real time. That doesn’t make interviews broken. It just means our approach needs to evolve.

Greenhouse TA Manager Bronté Chappell reminds us that the goal isn’t to police candidates – it’s to create conversations that surface the strengths AI can’t supply. Here are her tips:

1. Ask questions that reveal lived experience, not memorized responses

Prioritize behavioral and situational questions that require candidates to share what they did, how they made decisions and what they learned along the way. You’ll uncover real experience, self-awareness and learning agility – qualities AI tools can’t really fabricate.

2. Evaluate answers against outcomes – not just polish

A confident delivery is helpful, but it’s not the whole story. Use structured scorecards to look for evidence of skill, role readiness and impact a candidate has demonstrated in past work. Strong communication can elevate a response, but outcomes and examples should carry the weight.

3. Pay attention to how candidates collaborate in the conversation

It’s important to understand how someone engages: asking clarifying questions, responding thoughtfully to follow-ups, showing curiosity and building on ideas. These signals help you understand how they might partner with hiring managers, peers and cross-functional teams – not just whether they interview well.

Thank you

Thank you for reading this edition of Modern Recruiter! We’ll see you next time for more must-reads, events and open jobs to keep you updated on the latest news and insights in the industry.

Have questions or suggestions? Reply to this email.

Greenhouse Software, Inc.
228 Park Ave. S PMB 14744
New York, New York 10003-1502